The 2025-26 high school sports season on Long Island was a testament to the talent and dedication of student-athletes across the region. With over 30 state championship titles up for grabs, the competition was fierce, and the achievements of these teams are truly remarkable. Here's a deep dive into the top 10 teams that dominated their respective sports, showcasing the pinnacle of high school athletics.
1. Garden City Football: Unstoppable Force
Garden City football etched its name in history, becoming the most dominant force in New York State. Their 63-game winning streak, currently the nation's longest, is a testament to their unwavering excellence. With an average margin of victory of 33.4 points per game, the Trojans showcased their ability to overwhelm opponents. This team's success is not just about the wins; it's about the consistency and the culture they've cultivated. The Trojans' 13th Long Island championship and 10th straight county title speak volumes about their program's strength and longevity.
What makes Garden City's achievement even more impressive is their ability to maintain this level of success over multiple seasons. The team's current streak of 66 wins is a feat that few programs can match. The Trojans' dominance has earned them a place in the hearts of Long Island fans and has set a new standard for high school football.
2. St. Anthony's Girls Lacrosse: National Dominance
St. Anthony's girls lacrosse program continued its reign as a national powerhouse. Their 18-1 record and seventh straight CHSAA Class AA title are a testament to their skill and determination. The Friars' loss to Darien, the No. 1-ranked public school, served as a reminder of the competitive landscape. However, their response to this setback was remarkable, as they won 14 straight games to end the season.
The Friars' success is built on a strong foundation of Division I recruits, with 26 players earning that distinction. The team's third-place ranking in the nation further solidifies their status as a top program. With 13 of these recruits returning next season, St. Anthony's is poised to continue its dominance, leaving opponents in awe.
3. Half Hollow Hills Flag Football: Perfect Season
Half Hollow Hills flag football team had a season that felt inevitable from the start. Their perfect record, including a state championship victory over Shaker, showcased their prowess. The team's success was not just about the wins; it was about the style. They won all but two games by double digits, with Samantha Heyman throwing 70 touchdowns and Zoe Franks catching 27. The defense was equally impressive, with six shutouts.
The team's ability to maintain such a high level of performance throughout the season is a testament to their coaching and the players' dedication. Half Hollow Hills' perfect season is a rare feat in high school sports, and it has earned them a place in the history books.
4. Massapequa Football: Rising to the Challenge
Massapequa football team made history by becoming the first Nassau Class I team to win three straight Long Island titles. Their ability to overcome challenges, such as their victory over Oceanside and Ward Melville, showcased their resilience. The anticipation of a potential showdown with Garden City next year adds fuel to the fire.
Massapequa's success is a result of their consistent performance and the program's ability to develop talent. The team's leadership and determination have set a new standard for Nassau Class I football. With a chance to climb higher on the list, Massapequa is a force to be reckoned with.
5. St. Anthony's Boys Lacrosse: State Champions
St. Anthony's boys lacrosse team secured its seventh consecutive state title with a 13-12 victory over Chaminade. Their comeback-style wins and national ranking of No. 7 by USA Lacrosse further emphasize their excellence. Seven Friars, including Danny Rooney, a Newsday NSCHSAA/Private Player of the Year, were named to the All-Long Island team.
The Friars' success is a testament to their program's ability to develop and nurture talent. Their consistent state championships and national recognition are a source of pride for the school and the entire community.
6. St. Mary's Girls Basketball: State Champions
St. Mary's girls basketball team, led by Kayla Solomon, secured their state title in 2025-26. Solomon's 2,000th point and 29 points in the final showcased her exceptional talent. The Gaels' long-awaited state championship is a testament to their hard work and dedication.
The team's ability to overcome challenges and finally break through is a story of perseverance. St. Mary's' success has inspired the entire community and has set a new standard for girls' basketball on Long Island.
7. Sayville Girls Lacrosse: Undefeated Champions
Sayville girls lacrosse team had an undefeated season, winning their second state title in three years. Their dominance was evident in their wins, with Sophia Buffardi earning Newsday's Player of the Year award. The team's ability to win by at least five goals in all but four games showcased their depth and skill.
The Golden Flashes' success is a result of their strong program and the leadership of Buffardi, a UNC commit. Sayville's undefeated season is a testament to their ability to consistently perform at the highest level.
8. Ward Melville Co-ed Cheerleading: State Champions
Ward Melville's co-ed cheerleading team proved their dominance for the third year in a row. Ian Licavoli, Newsday's cheerleader of the year, led the team with terrific athleticism and leadership. The team's chants and performances were a sight to behold.
The Patriots' success is a testament to their program's ability to foster a sense of community and excellence. Ward Melville's cheerleading team has become a force to be reckoned with, bringing pride to the school and the entire community.
9. Commack Boys Soccer: State Champions
Commack boys soccer team dominated the season, averaging four goals per game and securing their first state Class AAA title since 2014. Their impressive record and performance in the playoffs showcased their talent and teamwork.
The Cougars' success is a result of their strong program and the leadership of Brayden O'Boyle, Newsday's Player of the Year. Commack's ability to dominate on both sides of the field has earned them a place among the top teams in the state.
10. Massapequa Boys Volleyball: State Champions
Massapequa boys volleyball team won their first state championship, showcasing their talent and determination. Behind Newsday's Player of the Year, Logan Coady, the team won 60 of 69 sets. Their success is a testament to their hard work and the program's ability to develop champions.
Massapequa's volleyball team has become a force to be reckoned with, winning their second straight county title and sixth in the last seven years. Their ability to consistently perform at a high level has earned them a place among the top teams in the state.
In conclusion, the 2025-26 high school sports season on Long Island was a showcase of talent, dedication, and excellence. These top 10 teams have set new standards for their respective sports and have inspired their communities. From football to lacrosse, basketball to cheerleading, these athletes have left their mark on the history books, reminding us of the power of hard work and perseverance.
